To use chat, please login.
Back to contacts

Myfxbook Autotrade

vontogr (togr)
Dec 13 2016 at 11:23
4862 posts
andyjen posted:
togr posted:
I did with this portfolio
https://www.myfxbook.com/members/togr/brest/1760977


Yes but that's a demo account

If that was a Live account then it would be a different matter

Why?
Vivi (ForexMechanism)
Dec 13 2016 at 11:23
14 posts
Well, even if its demo, I cant see whom all u subscribed.
Vivi (ForexMechanism)
Dec 13 2016 at 11:23
14 posts
Anyone who earned in real account ?
andyjen
Dec 13 2016 at 13:46
17 posts
togr posted:
andyjen posted:
togr posted:
I did with this portfolio
https://www.myfxbook.com/members/togr/brest/1760977


Yes but that's a demo account

If that was a Live account then it would be a different matter

Why?

for a long list of reasons

different spread, slippage, poor fills, etc.

trust me

what you get in your demo will be nowhere near your real results
Mitchel (mitchel14)
Dec 15 2016 at 17:25
58 posts
andyjen posted:
togr posted:
andyjen posted:
togr posted:
I did with this portfolio
https://www.myfxbook.com/members/togr/brest/1760977


Yes but that's a demo account

If that was a Live account then it would be a different matter

Why?

for a long list of reasons

different spread, slippage, poor fills, etc.

trust me

what you get in your demo will be nowhere near your real results


What sense do these results have in Demo if they are far from what would be real results?
vontogr (togr)
Dec 16 2016 at 08:42
4862 posts
andyjen posted:
togr posted:
andyjen posted:
togr posted:
I did with this portfolio
https://www.myfxbook.com/members/togr/brest/1760977


Yes but that's a demo account

If that was a Live account then it would be a different matter

Why?

for a long list of reasons

different spread, slippage, poor fills, etc.

trust me

what you get in your demo will be nowhere near your real results

you can always copy demo to real, with good broker the diff is small
rob559
Dec 16 2016 at 08:53
1916 posts
autotrade is great,
the only thing, i'd like is to be able to differenciate between live money acc suscribers and demo,acc suscribers,now we have no way to know do we?
andyjen
Dec 16 2016 at 09:17
17 posts
Ok I'll give you benefit of doubt

Have you got a link to your live account that shows the same % gain
andyjen
Dec 16 2016 at 09:17
17 posts
Also, how do you propose to copy the trades from demo to a live account. Manually?
vontogr (togr)
Dec 16 2016 at 09:44
4862 posts
andyjen posted:
Also, how do you propose to copy the trades from demo to a live account. Manually?

EA
Igor Furlan (ISFurlan)
Dec 16 2016 at 12:37
46 posts
togr posted:
andyjen posted:
Also, how do you propose to copy the trades from demo to a live account. Manually?

EA

Genius.
vontogr (togr)
Dec 16 2016 at 14:29
4862 posts
andyjen posted:
Also, how do you propose to copy the trades from demo to a live account. Manually?

Just to be clear you cannot copy autotrade demo to real. For obvious reason.
You can do it however with MT4 account.
elsa85
Dec 19 2016 at 15:00
11 posts
I would like understand how much a demo and real account are true. I have a demo account opened in may 2015, deposit 5000 usd. I used lucky pound and Atlas trader. Now account is at 270%, obviously is very good but in january i will open a real account, with the same deposit. How much return can I expect? I think is impossibile the same return of demo account, right? Slippage, commission, ecc... how much impact on the account? Thanks
Igor Furlan (ISFurlan)
Dec 19 2016 at 15:55
46 posts
elsa85 posted:
I would like understand how much a demo and real account are true. I have a demo account opened in may 2015, deposit 5000 usd. I used lucky pound and Atlas trader. Now account is at 270%, obviously is very good but in january i will open a real account, with the same deposit. How much return can I expect? I think is impossibile the same return of demo account, right? Slippage, commission, ecc... how much impact on the account? Thanks

Same question I have. In demo, everything is running ok and it's convincing me to start a real account. But I'm afraid the results would vary due to slippage, spread, and other conditions.
snowy
Dec 19 2016 at 17:03
78 posts
ISFurlan posted:
elsa85 posted:
I would like understand how much a demo and real account are true. I have a demo account opened in may 2015, deposit 5000 usd. I used lucky pound and Atlas trader. Now account is at 270%, obviously is very good but in january i will open a real account, with the same deposit. How much return can I expect? I think is impossibile the same return of demo account, right? Slippage, commission, ecc... how much impact on the account? Thanks

Same question I have. In demo, everything is running ok and it's convincing me to start a real account. But I'm afraid the results would vary due to slippage, spread, and other conditions.

You'll never have the same results because of the stated elements: difference in spread, slippage, time-delay while copying the trades, etc.
And don't forget the spread markup, with which the broker will charge you (for paying myfxbook). For example at Pepperstone the markup is around 0.8 pips for every pair.

But if you choose a good provider with a not-too-small pip-expectancy for each trade, who is not only trading during high spread-times (i.e. asian session scalper), then it should work. Can only tell if you try. :)
rob559
Dec 20 2016 at 07:24
1916 posts
ISFurlan posted:
elsa85 posted:
I would like understand how much a demo and real account are true. I have a demo account opened in may 2015, deposit 5000 usd. I used lucky pound and Atlas trader. Now account is at 270%, obviously is very good but in january i will open a real account, with the same deposit. How much return can I expect? I think is impossibile the same return of demo account, right? Slippage, commission, ecc... how much impact on the account? Thanks

Same question I have. In demo, everything is running ok and it's convincing me to start a real account. But I'm afraid the results would vary due to slippage, spread, and other conditions.

will be a bit different but not that much
elsa85
Dec 20 2016 at 07:25
11 posts
and how much the tax for the trader? if i gain 1000 usd for example, what is my real gain?
elsa85
Dec 20 2016 at 07:40
11 posts
thank you snowy, I know these difference. But I would like understand how much can be the difference about my demo account of 270%? can I gain 100% at least?
elsa85
Dec 20 2016 at 07:41
11 posts
I chose GDMFX provider...what do you think?
Vivi (ForexMechanism)
Dec 20 2016 at 07:58
14 posts
Guys, this is the biggest confusion even I have.

I have good experience in Demo except for some trades getting delayed in Demo as well. I spoke with a friend of mine who is in forex trading since long time. He told me that its obvious. I am optimistic about autotrade platform.

I am shocked no-one is ready to share their Live account experience on autotrade.
Please login to comment .