Forex Growth Bot Discussion

Does somebody know, if ThinkForex is a real ECN Broker (Pro Account)? How much are the commissions? There are only very few details on their website. Thanks.

What a naive comment. only about 5 initial trades were 1 lot which was my mistake and even closed in some loss


You should know by now the FGB increases lot sizes. Lot size is set to 0.1, so if a trades of 0.3 or 0.5 , its not a surprise. Every fgb user knows lot size increasing is a common issue with the bot.


I hope you got all the fgb losses today.. lol

Of course I taken all the losses that day (all month actually) as I will take all future earnings, with the same lot size. Lastest version of FGB doesnt double the size of the lot but if you are using a decompiled, older and custom version who knows ;)

Anyway you can stack your money play while looking for investors to gambling with them money.

Green pips 2 you,

   tapachula posted:
   

What a naive comment. only about 5 initial trades were 1 lot which was my mistake and even closed in some loss


You should know by now the FGB increases lot sizes. Lot size is set to 0.1, so if a trades of 0.3 or 0.5 , its not a surprise. Every fgb user knows lot size increasing is a common issue with the bot.


I hope you got all the fgb losses today.. lol

Of course I taken all the losses that day (all month actually) as I will take all future earnings, with the same lot size. Lastest version of FGB doesnt double the size of the lot but if you are using a decompiled, older and custom version who knows ;)

Anyway you can stack your money play while looking for investors to gambling with them money.

Green pips 2 you,

Dumb ... I have made it clear in my previous post that I am not here to Sell anything. Besides I have fixed the lot size issue and I will be going live by next week .

IF you are not aware here is the plan, My fgb gets almost all original fgb trades and more. So I will bag all fgb profitable trades and even more and end up being twice or thrice as profitable as Original fgb would be,

Assume my fgb starts taking losses in a worst case scenario and Original fgb wakes up I simply swap them and continue making profits, if in the futrue fgb starts taking losses I swap again and keep making profits, this way I can be more than thrice as profitable, I win on short and Long run. You should understand there is no set and forget. Market behaviour would change and if you must win continously then you must be willin to change with it else stomach periodic consecutive losses...


GOT IT ?..

Cheers

I had 3 short open trades from yesterday, I can't understand why FGB closed one at +65 pips meanwhile the trend was still down direction 😡

   GianniCascoNero posted:
   I had 3 short open trades from yesterday, I can't understand why FGB closed one at +65 pips meanwhile the trend was still down direction 😡

You should clearly see the trend is reversing my friend.. FGB made a wise decision

   RalFxify posted:
   

   GianniCascoNero posted:
   I had 3 short open trades from yesterday, I can't understand why FGB closed one at +65 pips meanwhile the trend was still down direction 😡

You should clearly see the trend is reversing my friend.. FGB made a wise decision

so better manually close other 2 trades 😐

If you think you're a good enough trader to time exits of FGB manually then you're probably better off trading manually. Personally I say leave it alone to do it's own thing.

Here myfxbook again has an update problem with FGB. The last updated time seems to be 45 minutes a go, as of 01 March 15.00 GMT

hi steve, are u make FGB ?, from your statement, if u don't like please leave, what is the meaning, we are here to discuss to make FGB better and better, please sorry if u don't like my statement.. please remove it

This just does not work this way, they got to find a solution for the members of FGB EA to follow original positions from some source.
Ok, brokers differentiate I understand, but I want to see FGB EA`s original positions from its broker to double check, when it open positions in my broker.
This myfxbook can not track it with a live update, and it is open to everybody. This is not the right way to do it.

   cendolcilik posted:
   hi steve, are u make FGB ?, from your statement, if u don't like please leave, what is the meaning, we are here to discuss to make FGB better and better, please sorry if u don't like my statement.. please remove it

Hi, no I didn't make FGB. Wish I had.

All I'm saying is that from time to time FGB will suffer drawdowns, as can be seen from it's trading record, but it always recovers. The problem occurs when the markets get choppy. Predicting when this will happen and working it into an EA is almost impossible. The EA has a ten year backtest history and a solid trading basis to believe the results of that backtest. I'm sure there are tweaks that can be made but overall I think it's average monthly return is phenomenal. You just have to be patient and after several years you will be pretty wealthy.

I haven't seen any other FGB accounts that have been profitable over the last 6 months. Perhaps the FGB team are manually intervening with this account.

I can confirm that the trades on here pretty much match the trades I get with the Alpari account I started a few weeks ago.

I would guess the opposite is likely, that people are manually closing their own FGB trades thinking that they know better where the markets are likely to go.

   SmoothHedge posted:
   I haven't seen any other FGB accounts that have been profitable over the last 6 months. Perhaps the FGB team are manually intervening with this account.

Offcourse I believe that, moreover I didn't take last profittable trades because EA was locked in VERIFYING, it's not the first time I have problems like that, this EA is a b****it

My trades have been matching GB pretty closely. Make your DD regarding brokers. This is a highly sensitive robot to brokers.

   prototipo posted:
   

   SmoothHedge posted:
   I haven't seen any other FGB accounts that have been profitable over the last 6 months. Perhaps the FGB team are manually intervening with this account.

Offcourse I believe that, moreover I didn't take last profittable trades because EA was locked in VERIFYING, it's not the first time I have problems like that, this EA is a b****it

agree

Again... losses. This EA always trades in the correct side of the market, but wait too much to take the profits, what allowing them to become it in losses. Once achieve that, the EA take the losses. Look the down trend in the 1 hour chart. Since the 2/29 the price doesn't do other thing that falling. And this EA had made only sales. The EA was right always, but despite it, only collected mostly losses
(I hope my bad English be understand, my language is Spanish)

   betowm posted:
   Again... losses. This EA always trades in the correct side of the market, but wait too much to take the profits, what allowing them to become it in losses. Once achieve that, the EA take the losses. Look the down trend in the 1 hour chart. Since the 2/29 the price doesn't do other thing that falling. And this EA had made only sales. The EA was right always, but despite it, only collected mostly losses
(I hope my bad English be understand, my language is Spanish)

Agree, yesterday was +130pips...and today close in loss 😭
I think FGB have a bad close strategy.

The close strategy is as good as the profits made so far! It's impossible for anyone - software or human - to predict where is the best low/high price for closing a sell/buy order. You all expect FGB to do supra-natural work. Well, just wait... The same strategy produced 1700% gain. If you do not want looses, feel free to manually close any positive trade you are pleased with, but do not come here then to express your frustration about not letting it a little bit more on that positive trade. Same goes for negative P/L. Don't try to bee rich doing nothing but complaining. Do your homework and at least read all the thread. Your complaints have been already discussed before and there're are some resolutions.

Good luck!