To use chat, please login.
Back to contacts

KeltnerPRO - Jared (By keltnerpro )

Gain : +5645.75%
Drawdown 58.74%
Pips: 4744.8
Trades 1003
Won:
Lost:
Type: Real
Leverage: 1:100
Trading: Unknown

KeltnerPRO - Jared Discussion

prasansg29
Aug 24 2016 at 05:25
6 posts
Thanks for all the honest reply. Thus any reliable EA for signal start? Thanks.

InsiderBCN
Oct 17 2016 at 09:55
8 posts
Anyone can share their experience with that system?

FXbrokertester (vgasper)
Oct 17 2016 at 19:55
89 posts
InsiderBCN posted:
Anyone can share their experience with that system?


Two systems with history...

Attachments:


Im writing about my experiences, so yours can be different ;)
Xamarass
Nov 08 2016 at 12:06
52 posts
InsiderBCN posted:
Anyone can share their experience with that system?


Hi you can search in myfxbook with key word 'Keltner' and you will find several cases
(big part of them with Keltner Pro).
My personal experience is positive with around 43% in 9 months.
Keltner Pro is a key part of my forex strategy and I'm happy with it.
The DD is increasing and trading frequency is reducing (I don't like that).
Having a precise idea about when to stop the EA I don't care and in the worst
case I will temporary stop. Indeedly on October 7 very bad situation with unexpected
loss.
Cheers

Find an edge and trade it
jialin
Nov 29 2016 at 08:09
3 posts
By go through history test with tds, I find the 2 critical elements to make this ea successful are:
1. its winning rate is around 48%-53%
2. its rr ratio is about 1.4-1.6
now here is my question, the winning rate will be lower if we setup maxopenposition=1(usually 5% lower than we setup maxopenposition=3), so it looks like the second and third trades average up the overall winning rate. Is that possible we can get higher winning rate if we skip the first trade and just open second and third trades?

FXbrokertester (vgasper)
Dec 12 2016 at 12:23
89 posts
This one is more reliable for watch:

https://www.myfxbook.com/members/forexgermany/keltnerpro/983876

Im writing about my experiences, so yours can be different ;)
fxtarpan
Feb 09 2017 at 07:55
109 posts
keltnerpro posted:
Because I have plenty of other accounts not shown, this is my re-investment account used for proof and used to build up a nest egg
for the future.


What is the minimun deposit recomended for this EA...?... And broker,,,?...
Thanks.

Ryan Brown (lilredry)
Feb 21 2017 at 18:51
7 posts
Guys, This account is a demo...KeltnerPro is duping his viewers. He's NEVER made a withdraw EVER! If you REALLY want to know if his account is real have him make a -$20 withdraw from his $300k+ account.

Prove me wrong KetlerPro!


Gebbe
Feb 22 2017 at 08:04
4 posts
besttools posted:

Drawdown: 58.74% is big risk...


And you Withdrawals: $0.00 !!!!!!

you use free demo bonus deposit !!!!!!!!! LOL

A B M Faruque Rahman (monirainvestment)
Apr 13 2017 at 06:48
14 posts
Gebbe posted:
besttools posted:

Drawdown: 58.74% is big risk...


And you Withdrawals: $0.00 !!!!!!

you use free demo bonus deposit !!!!!!!!! LOL


big return as well.

High risk strategy is thousand times better than low risk.
You have to just withdraw capital (50%) every year.

Plan Your Trade. Trade Your Plan.
HardWorker
Apr 16 2017 at 07:26
4 posts
Hi, keltnerpro.

Why no trade from 02.17.2017 to now? what is wrong with the EA of KeltnerPRO?

Art of Trader (M725179)
Apr 28 2017 at 11:10
12 posts
the strategy is so volatility

I think Keltnerpro would confuse on the EA strategy as well

vocasla
Jun 27 2017 at 06:29
35 posts
Issues of volatility can be ironed out by implementing 3 simple things:

1) Only allowing 1 trade per pair at a time
2) Keeping to fixed lots and only increase lots (manually) at new equity highs
3) Adding more currency pairs and at different time frames

To continue making this EA work smoothly (as is the case for me) - I've added/modified the following pairs/timeframes (they've all been backtested):

AUDUSD M5,
EURGBP H1,
EURUSD M15, EURUSD M30,
GBPUSD M5, GBPUSD M15,
NZDUSD M15,
USDCHF M5, USDCHF M15
USDJPY M15

Lot sizing will need to be re-adjusted as well as there are duplicate pairs (i.e. EURUSD, GBPUSD, and USDCHF) plus they all perform at different frequencies and profitabilities, historically speaking (this is optional).

For a $10k start balance, lot sizes could be:

AUDUSD = 0.12
EURGBP = 0.12
EURUSD = 0.02 (0.02*2=0.04)
GBPUSD = 0.02 (0.02*2=0.04)
NZDUSD = 0.12
USDCHF = 0.02 (0.02*2=0.04)
USDJPY = 0.12

Of course, one could just stick to the standard fixed 0.01 lot per $1k rule to keep things simple.

*Note: there's probably a few more timeframes / currency pairs that could work to create a great combo (i.e. H1 timeframe, SGD currency pair). You'll need to perform your own backtests to check if they are satisfactory to your preferences.

Here's a portfolio backtest (max drawdown hovers around ~10%):






Attachments:


- TimeWarp to 2030 -
Ozzie Matt (aeronthomas)
Jul 06 2017 at 09:46
1557 posts
vocasla posted:
Issues of volatility can be ironed out by implementing 3 simple things:

1) Only allowing 1 trade per pair at a time
2) Keeping to fixed lots and only increase lots (manually) at new equity highs
3) Adding more currency pairs and at different time frames

To continue making this EA work smoothly (as is the case for me) - I've added/modified the following pairs/timeframes (they've all been backtested):

AUDUSD M5,
EURGBP H1,
EURUSD M15, EURUSD M30,
GBPUSD M5, GBPUSD M15,
NZDUSD M15,
USDCHF M5, USDCHF M15
USDJPY M15

Lot sizing will need to be re-adjusted as well as there are duplicate pairs (i.e. EURUSD, GBPUSD, and USDCHF) plus they all perform at different frequencies and profitabilities, historically speaking (this is optional).

For a $10k start balance, lot sizes could be:

AUDUSD = 0.12
EURGBP = 0.12
EURUSD = 0.02 (0.02*2=0.04)
GBPUSD = 0.02 (0.02*2=0.04)
NZDUSD = 0.12
USDCHF = 0.02 (0.02*2=0.04)
USDJPY = 0.12

Of course, one could just stick to the standard fixed 0.01 lot per $1k rule to keep things simple.

*Note: there's probably a few more timeframes / currency pairs that could work to create a great combo (i.e. H1 timeframe, SGD currency pair). You'll need to perform your own backtests to check if they are satisfactory to your preferences.

Here's a portfolio backtest (max drawdown hovers around ~10%):







Am I reading these results right, 152% return over a 16 year period with 10% max drawdown. This seems like a very low return for such a long backtest?

FXtrader2010
Jul 06 2017 at 19:21
724 posts
aeronthomas posted:
vocasla posted:
Issues of volatility can be ironed out by implementing 3 simple things:

1) Only allowing 1 trade per pair at a time
2) Keeping to fixed lots and only increase lots (manually) at new equity highs
3) Adding more currency pairs and at different time frames

To continue making this EA work smoothly (as is the case for me) - I've added/modified the following pairs/timeframes (they've all been backtested):

AUDUSD M5,
EURGBP H1,
EURUSD M15, EURUSD M30,
GBPUSD M5, GBPUSD M15,
NZDUSD M15,
USDCHF M5, USDCHF M15
USDJPY M15

Lot sizing will need to be re-adjusted as well as there are duplicate pairs (i.e. EURUSD, GBPUSD, and USDCHF) plus they all perform at different frequencies and profitabilities, historically speaking (this is optional).

For a $10k start balance, lot sizes could be:

AUDUSD = 0.12
EURGBP = 0.12
EURUSD = 0.02 (0.02*2=0.04)
GBPUSD = 0.02 (0.02*2=0.04)
NZDUSD = 0.12
USDCHF = 0.02 (0.02*2=0.04)
USDJPY = 0.12

Of course, one could just stick to the standard fixed 0.01 lot per $1k rule to keep things simple.

*Note: there's probably a few more timeframes / currency pairs that could work to create a great combo (i.e. H1 timeframe, SGD currency pair). You'll need to perform your own backtests to check if they are satisfactory to your preferences.

Here's a portfolio backtest (max drawdown hovers around ~10%):







Am I reading these results right, 152% return over a 16 year period with 10% max drawdown. This seems like a very low return for such a long backtest?
i dunno seems pretty good to me. Not many investments can achieve such great of a return with such low risk,

vocasla
Jul 07 2017 at 05:57
35 posts
aeronthomas posted:

Am I reading these results right, 152% return over a 16 year period with 10% max drawdown. This seems like a very low return for such a long backtest?


Leverage was set to fixed lot in order to show the underlying performance and minimize visual bias i.e. observe that the Stability factor = 0.89. With auto-lot function, the net gain in percent would be higher than that, with greater drawdown. I didn't show here the compound annual growth rate (CAGR).

Also note, I didn't do any analysis of winrate changes over time, either. So the statistical analysis above is fairly limited.

I merely wanted to show stability over time up to the present.

- TimeWarp to 2030 -
Ozzie Matt (aeronthomas)
Jul 12 2017 at 11:09
1557 posts
vocasla posted:
aeronthomas posted:

Am I reading these results right, 152% return over a 16 year period with 10% max drawdown. This seems like a very low return for such a long backtest?


Leverage was set to fixed lot in order to show the underlying performance and minimize visual bias i.e. observe that the Stability factor = 0.89. With auto-lot function, the net gain in percent would be higher than that, with greater drawdown. I didn't show here the compound annual growth rate (CAGR).

Also note, I didn't do any analysis of winrate changes over time, either. So the statistical analysis above is fairly limited.

I merely wanted to show stability over time up to the present.
Okay that explains it. Yes with compounding and increasing lot sizes it would be very interesting to see results.

vocasla
Jul 18 2017 at 06:57
35 posts
Here's a more comprehensive list of pairs:

AUDCHF M30,
AUDNZD M5,
AUDUSD M5,
EURGBP H1,
EURUSD M15, EURUSD M30,
GBPUSD M5, GBPUSD M15, GBPUSD M30, GBPUSD H1
GBPSGD M15,
NZDUSD M15,
USDCHF M5, USDCHF M15
USDJPY M15, USDJPY M30

- TimeWarp to 2030 -
FXbrokertester (vgasper)
Jul 26 2017 at 14:36
89 posts
This is the right picture of this EA: https://www.myfxbook.com/members/forexgermany/keltnerpro/983876

Thanks to the trader who is putting all results online...

Im writing about my experiences, so yours can be different ;)
alasdeaguila12
Jul 28 2017 at 19:49
18 posts
thanks for share list of pairs etc, gbpusd looks very bad eurusd / usdchf in forexgermany looks better, Anyone can recommend good breakout from mql5?

Please login to comment .