I think many people look at the ranking and not the details.

Constant lot size

diversity over many pairs

trading on consistent patterns ( same Candle)

What a great day wonderful TPs today!!!!!!!

FXActionToday posted:
Not bad. 5 days listing got me over 10K investment fund (well, i am currently top 1 at 5% DD and 100% win rate).

I have been using FX Junction and MQL% since 2012, Signal Stat is not bad. Will continue use it and see how it goes.

Thank you.

[email protected]

I have 9 followers with total 90 thousand dollars following my trades, keep going.

good

Not bad. 5 days listing got me over 10K investment fund (well, i am currently top 1 at 5% DD and 100% win rate).

I have been using FX Junction and MQL% since 2012, Signal Stat is not bad. Will continue use it and see how it goes.

Thank you.

[email protected]

Good service, easy to set up, highly recommend!

Mattywhitt73 posted:
not too bad a bit misleading as the trader can hide some losing trades as I have been copying for 2 weeks and not all my losses show in the copy traders account???/?????

All of mine match exactly

Mattywhitt73 posted:
not too bad a bit misleading as the trader can hide some losing trades as I have been copying for 2 weeks and not all my losses show in the copy traders account???/?????

Really need to fix this. I was trusting the signals thinking i had a better success rate only to have the signals wipe out my account. If you email them the will add back the losing trades but you really have to be counting all the losing trades yourself.

not too bad a bit misleading as the trader can hide some losing trades as I have been copying for 2 weeks and not all my losses show in the copy traders account???/?????

hb

Very bad. Blocking account is a normal practise here.

Great copy trading platform, I actually prefer Signal Start over it's main competitor SimpleTrader.

I agree. I slipped way way down the list, for no apparent reason.
What's happening SignalStart?

Ranking is broken beyond repair....repeated emails yet no reply.

OutsideTheBoxHK posted:
I whole heartedly agree with Matei21 in last post.
There seems to be either:

1- an outdated inferior system of calculating the rankings (many ways to evaluate them based on real trading system benefits)
2- a calculation system that is intentionally incentivizing poor trading just for profit of their business model

Agree this system I copy and has made me a great deal of $$ went from rank 38 to 162 in 4 hours yet was making winning trades


One of the things not rated is consistency in lot size this is so very important for us to control risk

Oh and now the rank is 182

Yet I see in the top 100 many systems have many many loosing months in the past few months

Broken Ranking System

I think everyone must think his own head, no rank can help here. Everyone want, that somebody calculate a good signal and give him ready product. If you need super stable signals, why are you here, go to autotrade Myfxbook, there you'll find what you want.

I whole heartedly agree with Matei21 in last post.
There seems to be either:

1- an outdated inferior system of calculating the rankings (many ways to evaluate them based on real trading system benefits)
2- a calculation system that is intentionally incentivizing poor trading just for profit of their business model

Hi. I had some problems with their website regarding the Investor pass on my accounts. I have e-mailed their support and they were very fast in response and took care of the problem asap. I would appreciate some sort of modification to their formula for ranking the signals as some signals are very good the first month and then they do not trade much just to stay on top. I think the good signals that are more than 2-3 months old and have good steady performance and safe DD should be higher up in the ranking. This way the subscribers would be more happy and trade more safer for the long term. Just my opinion.

cmack99 posted:
There's a lot of comments in this discussion, but it would be greatly beneficial if all would list which signals they are subscribed to and are commenting about.

Admin dont let advertise on this thread this is why no one is stating which signals they are following.

for example charlesalan is following my trades you can PM him to ask details.

Very good.