Ak chcete používať chat, prihláste sa.
Späť na Kontakty

ZuluTrade Skóre recenzií


Celkové skóre: 2.8 / 5

Celkový počet hlasov: 148
Ziskovosť
1
Platforma
1
Ceny
1
Zákaznícky servis
1
1 - najhorší 5 - najlepší

ZuluTrade Diskusia

72 príspevkov
i just stoped zulu ... the guard function is just taking out all the fun
13 príspevkov
I really love ZuluTrade, I have made a lot of money with it, without having to worry about trading at all.

Remember you can always start with a Demo account.

Never forget that as with all Forex system, money management is a must! Keep a reasonable and safe lot size!
Plan for the worst and hope for the best - Check my PAMM Account!
80 príspevkov
Good service, i think waiting 15 seconds before placing the next trade is a downside but this eliminates errors experienced with followers, or tries to atleast. The concern for me is 1. the main focus on pips should not be the prime performance indicator of a trader. more pips or less does not equte to good trading or capital growth. you could make 10 pips on USDCAD, but loss 300 on USDDKK, but still be up on balance this could be simply due to money management, you may have a larger position on USDCAD and a small position on USDDKK. So where on earth did those knuckleheads think okay lets plot the traders performace based on how much pips he/she makes.

2. The idea of a PAMM or mirror trading is i have an account of 100,000 USD and you have 10,000 USD, if i go long USDCAD 1 lot you should go long 0.1 lot. 10 percent of my trade size naturally because you have 10 percent the account size of mine. Simple math. Now what Zulutrade have gone and done, part genius part zulu influence if you know what i mean, they introduced the follower the power to allocate their desired risk. Seems safe, but its not. Its a mess to be frank. The system is smart it works out the traders performance and will adjust trade sizes along throughout the week/month. Or daily the trader could adjust his risk to lower or higher depending on his gut feeling or depending on what side of the bed he woke up.
I mean seriously isnt the whole idea of someone following me mean they dont know what they are doing so now you give them the wheel at the pivotal moment when i execute a trade they 'gamble' the amount. I trust you see the irony in this. Zulutrade have gone horribly wrong here in my opinion and when i confronted them about it they said it is what it is, they dont offer pamm they have their own system and well if it works for some great. But consider very carefully what i just wrote.

Money management is as important as the strategy so why on earth should the person following have a hand in making that decision.. ludicrous.

For a final note, having to wait 15 seconds min to place or adjust a position is farcical, time is money etc and then on top of having to wait to ensure the trades make it to my followers some can still be missed. This equals risk.

Try before you buy, but otherwise there are some good providers.
We are all faced with a series of great opportunities, brilliantly disguised as unsolvable problems - John W Gardener
35 príspevkov
shinobi_brian posted:
I am one - check out shinobi_trader and shinobi_trader2:

https://www.zulutrade.com/TradeHistoryIndividual.aspx?pid=90316
https://www.zulutrade.com/TradeHistoryIndividual.aspx?pid=91725

Everything is OK and working now.
8 príspevkov
1 príspevkov
I am sure there is....those that actually made some money trading :)
35 príspevkov
2 príspevkov

   stevetrade posted:
   If they put this forward as the premise for the business then that would be fair enough, however this is what they claim to be:

'What is ZuluTrade ?

ZuluTrade bridged the gap between valuable information in money markets and trade execution, by converting the advice of professional and talented traders globally to an executed trade rapidly and automatically in your account (from supported brokers)

There was a time when trading was a headache. Not anymore! You don't have to study or monitor the market to make a good pick, because hundreds of industry well-known experts from all over the world are doing it for you. All you have to do is pick the experts you like, and ZuluTrade will quickly convert their advice into live trades in your trading account directly with the broker. And the best of all, it's completely FREE!*

ZuluTrade receives rebates from the brokers, for the trades generated and splits them with the experts that provide the advice. Check the performance results recommended by our experts here'

Now if it was to say

'ZuluTrade is a site full of dodgy chancers, sprinkled with a handful of decent traders. If you are prepared to spend ages sorting out the wheat from the chaff and have a degree in statistical analysis there is a small chance our highly flaky platform might convert some of those trades into one or two pip winners for you.'

That would be a fairer representation of the business model.
yes u say the true thank u so much
9 príspevkov
New ranking again, this time I think they got it right! 😉
11 príspevkov
1 good strategy is to use a own signal account and follow with affiliate account so you get 0.9 pips back and external providers comissions are covered

email me for details ( no -us)
9 príspevkov
So this means you used a broker with 1pip/trade commission and you opened 200 mini lots in one month? If this is the case, you either lost everything or gained like 1-2k at least, which in both cases the $200 commission is nothing IMO...Maybe you should open less lots? It sounds a bit risky strategy
5 príspevkov

   markopolo posted:
   With which broker? And you mean you paid in commissions or you lost $200? You cant have paid $200 in commissions, unless you have a huge account and trade in standard lots!
Yes, it was commission, and my account was not so big $3000
49 príspevkov
With which broker? And you mean you paid in commissions or you lost $200? You cant have paid $200 in commissions, unless you have a huge account and trade in standard lots!
5 príspevkov
they says that the service 'FOR FREE', but this is not true I have paid in one month more that $200, I never will work with them any more.
1 príspevkov

   mrhulu posted:
   Too high spread. I'm expect profit but I got nothing with this SP.

Which providers are you using? Post some screenshots of your live account....
1 príspevkov
Too high spread. I'm expect profit but I got nothing with this SP.
2 príspevkov
1 príspevkov

   andrewl posted:
   I have to disagree with you.
In order to attract live accounts and keep making those rebates, you HAVE to be a good trader. Either wise, you make a few bucks as a provider for 1-2 months, then you just burn! Live followers are not stupid and will stop following you when you mess up!


I also tend to agree with the statement above. There are quite prominent and a follower easily understands who will bring him/her money. The system is very professional based to show via a comprehensive database of a large pool of signal providers available, thus enabling the viewer to find the signal providers with the best ratio of winning trades; best pip count; average profit per trade;average trade execution time;maximum draw down and number of investors subscribed.
9 príspevkov
I have to disagree with you.
In order to attract live accounts and keep making those rebates, you HAVE to be a good trader. Either wise, you make a few bucks as a provider for 1-2 months, then you just burn! Live followers are not stupid and will stop following you when you mess up!
13 príspevkov
The idea of Zulutrade is quite interesting but unfortunately not profitable, at least not for me. The reason is that absolutely everybody can become a signal provider. You just have to sign up, make 31 trades and your profile goes online no matter how bad the results.
Since the signal providers get payed per trade most of them have developed certain technics to make as many trades as possible and not as much profit as possible. They close positions with minimal profit just to open the same possition again, they open countless possitions on the same currency pair, or they don't set SL witch often leads to big DDs.
This system probably works for Zulutrade and for the signalproviders but it hardly works for their followers.
Ak chcete komentovať, prihláste sa .