Advertisement
REV Trader PRO REAL (Genom revtraderpro)
| Förstärkning : | +3474.7% |
| Uttag | 24.25% |
| Pips: | 3809.5 |
| Trades | 938 |
| Won: |
|
| Förlorad: |
|
| Typ: | Verkligt |
| Hävstångseffekt: | 1:400 |
| Handel: | Automatiserad |
REV Trader PRO REAL Diskussion
Jan 16, 2015 at 12:38
Hi folks,
There are several things that bother me
1º) Why the oficial acount of revpro, this one, has 3 trades opened right now, while mine and some others closed them yesterday.
2º) It seems it is not posible to backtest the ea at mt4.
3º) Dough Price dont seem very interested in answering questions and supporting people that bought his ea.
I see that the ea is working on these premises: entry point is the high or low, filtered with the 80/20 stocastic oscilator level, following the daily trend (down or high) and did a manual back test of these conditions for the last 5 years. The last year, 2014 was wonderful, but the other 4 were depressing. Obviously, I have done it manually and did not take all my time, but Dough should answer these questions.....and I keep asking them to him, but he does not seem very interested,
There are several things that bother me
1º) Why the oficial acount of revpro, this one, has 3 trades opened right now, while mine and some others closed them yesterday.
2º) It seems it is not posible to backtest the ea at mt4.
3º) Dough Price dont seem very interested in answering questions and supporting people that bought his ea.
I see that the ea is working on these premises: entry point is the high or low, filtered with the 80/20 stocastic oscilator level, following the daily trend (down or high) and did a manual back test of these conditions for the last 5 years. The last year, 2014 was wonderful, but the other 4 were depressing. Obviously, I have done it manually and did not take all my time, but Dough should answer these questions.....and I keep asking them to him, but he does not seem very interested,
Medlem sedan Feb 09, 2010
224 inlägg
Jan 16, 2015 at 12:44
jesus posted:
Hi folks,
There are several things that bother me
1º) Why the oficial acount of revpro, this one, has 3 trades opened right now, while mine and some others closed them yesterday.
2º) It seems it is not posible to backtest the ea at mt4.
3º) Dough Price dont seem very interested in answering questions and supporting people that bought his ea.
I see that the ea is working on these premises: entry point is the high or low, filtered with the 80/20 stocastic oscilator level, following the daily trend (down or high) and did a manual back test of these conditions for the last 5 years. The last year, 2014 was wonderful, but the other 4 were depressing. Obviously, I have done it manually and did not take all my time, but Dough should answer these questions.....and I keep asking them to him, but he does not seem very interested,
I agree there should be more attention to the thread here from the developer.
I also have three trades open and I think its because we got the signal twice. First time was good and it took a profit on two trades and then proceeded to open three more trades in AUDUSD.
We all have different broker feeds which would make the indicators come up with different results.....thats the reason why we have slightly different trades.....
As I have said a few times on this forum - WHAT HAPPENS WHEN YOU TWEAK THE TP and SL? I've noticed the entries with this EA are very good. The only thing I suspect needs to change is the fixed TP and SL settings because it may be that in the future those settings are just too ambitious so they may need to be reduced. Or it may be that they are too low so they may need to be increased. The entry is just as important as the exit and I think the entry is ok for the moment. I don't know what others opinions are on this or even Doug's view. I'd appreciate his view too.
Medlem sedan Oct 03, 2010
155 inlägg
Jan 16, 2015 at 12:58
How is this EA treating the SL? Will it close the position once it reaches the SL in pips? Or is it working with basket trading?
Medlem sedan Oct 11, 2014
106 inlägg
Jan 16, 2015 at 14:50
goode posted:
@revtraderpro hi vendor,these audusd what do you think? keep opening the weekend or let's close before the market closed 30mins?
we hope you give us advice or just send e-mail to all clients.
If it keeps going the way it's going I will most likely let it close for weekend.
Medlem sedan Oct 11, 2014
106 inlägg
Jan 16, 2015 at 14:51
It's not easy to spend all day on here. I do my best to check in from time to time.
1) different price feeds.
2) It's very slow.
1) different price feeds.
2) It's very slow.
jesus posted:
Hi folks,
There are several things that bother me
1º) Why the oficial acount of revpro, this one, has 3 trades opened right now, while mine and some others closed them yesterday.
2º) It seems it is not posible to backtest the ea at mt4.
3º) Dough Price dont seem very interested in answering questions and supporting people that bought his ea.
Medlem sedan Jan 10, 2015
7 inlägg
Jan 16, 2015 at 15:41
revtraderpro posted:
2) It's very slow.
So, is it real to backtest EA? What do u think about this backtest
? I see the major diff between test results and yours from Jan'14 to Oct'14...
Medlem sedan Oct 11, 2014
106 inlägg
Jan 16, 2015 at 15:44
supernova01 posted:revtraderpro posted:
2) It's very slow.
So, is it real to backtest EA? What do u think about this backtest
We are on v2.5 ... updates have improved it overtime so backtest a year ago may not be same as today... BUT more importantly the robot continues to work and do well... Please stop posting this dribble, this has been discussed multiple times already.
Medlem sedan Jan 25, 2010
1288 inlägg
Jan 16, 2015 at 16:12
supernova01 posted:
http://twathochties.blogspot.co.uk/2014/11/rev-trader-pro-should-it-stay-or-should.html
"All things considered" (as they say...). Quite in-depth analysis - a lot of effort was put into that. But as always, results will vary depending upon many factors, especially broker's feed, systems used (servers, latency), etc.
revtraderpro posted:😲
Please stop posting this dribble, this has been discussed multiple times already.
Hmmm...
“The trouble with most of us is that we'd rather be ruined by praise than saved by criticism.”
― Norman Vincent Peale
“To avoid criticism say nothing, do nothing, be nothing.”
― Aristotle
Medlem sedan May 10, 2011
193 inlägg
Jan 16, 2015 at 16:16
supernova01 posted:
http://twathochties.blogspot.co.uk/2014/11/rev-trader-pro-should-it-stay-or-should.html
Doug told me that latest version is needed, and my thoughts further is that Walk-Forward-Analysis is in order (i.e., optruns in sections of past followed by "walk forward" test......there is such a software that controls mt4 to do this, but strangely, its only now available as trial.....anyone know why? Not compatible with v600+'s? Oh well, so doing manually is possible, except doing this HUGE project within 60 day guarantee most likely not possible.)
don't believe 99.9% of the EA e-ads out there my friends!
Medlem sedan Jan 10, 2015
7 inlägg
Jan 16, 2015 at 17:44
And why do you not want to backtest v2.5? I really can buy it if you proof another point.
Medlem sedan Oct 11, 2014
106 inlägg
Jan 16, 2015 at 18:01
supernova01 posted:
And why do you not want to backtest v2.5? I really can buy it if you proof another point.
If you want to enjoy the winning trades, purchase, if not, don't.
Medlem sedan Oct 11, 2014
106 inlägg
Jan 16, 2015 at 18:28
supernova01 posted:
And why do you not want to backtest v2.5? I really can buy it if you proof another point.
Also your welcome to back test if you like.
Medlem sedan Jan 10, 2015
7 inlägg
Jan 16, 2015 at 21:55
marketing lvl 99
Medlem sedan Jan 10, 2015
7 inlägg
Jan 17, 2015 at 10:32
well, i will purchase it, but if i'll see notprofitable trading in 2011-2013 u will give me 10k$, ok?
forex_trader_205306
Medlem sedan Aug 27, 2014
13 inlägg
Jan 17, 2015 at 10:33
I already posted that the EA had a DD of 40% just on AUDUSD trading 3 orders at 3% risk.
If you set more than 3%, it would be more.
Question is we don't know when the other pairs will go into DD together, and that would blow the account.
The CHF event proved the point. So you have to decide if you want to set the risk more than 3% and trade 3 orders.
Good luck.
If you set more than 3%, it would be more.
Question is we don't know when the other pairs will go into DD together, and that would blow the account.
The CHF event proved the point. So you have to decide if you want to set the risk more than 3% and trade 3 orders.
Good luck.
Medlem sedan Apr 18, 2014
29 inlägg
Jan 17, 2015 at 10:35
Week 2 results for REV Trader Pro(FXCM and VPS):
- Total of 397 pips profit
- 10 trades/8 winners/2 losers (80% win percentage)
- I did not manually manipulate any trades
This EA is working exactly as it is designed and configured to do. I just do not get why some people are manually manipulating trades, it is a robot, it is meant to be left alone to do its thing. If you want to manual trade this robot, do not complain about its performance. I can see why Mr. Price is getting short with some of those on the thread, if your not following the configuration guidelines or running it properly, you should keep your comment to yourselves.... IMO
- Total of 397 pips profit
- 10 trades/8 winners/2 losers (80% win percentage)
- I did not manually manipulate any trades
This EA is working exactly as it is designed and configured to do. I just do not get why some people are manually manipulating trades, it is a robot, it is meant to be left alone to do its thing. If you want to manual trade this robot, do not complain about its performance. I can see why Mr. Price is getting short with some of those on the thread, if your not following the configuration guidelines or running it properly, you should keep your comment to yourselves.... IMO
RULES!!! RULES!!! RULES!!!!
Jan 17, 2015 at 10:38
RTP now has the best setup for currently market behavior. Each year the market has more or less movement if you can remember, different FED's chairman like Bernanke and Yellen.... QE ... OIL PRICE ... as a trader we have to learn the market then fine tune the system.
In my opinion, the backtest more than a year or two cannot justify the performance of the EA.
I hope Mr.Price will keep continue update his EA for us when the game has changed.
cheers.😂
In my opinion, the backtest more than a year or two cannot justify the performance of the EA.
I hope Mr.Price will keep continue update his EA for us when the game has changed.
cheers.😂
Medlem sedan May 10, 2011
193 inlägg
Jan 17, 2015 at 21:02
LibertyHound posted:
Week 2 results for REV Trader Pro(FXCM and VPS):
- Total of 397 pips profit
- 10 trades/8 winners/2 losers (80% win percentage)
- I did not manually manipulate any trades
This EA is working exactly as it is designed and configured to do. I just do not get why some people are manually manipulating trades, it is a robot, it is meant to be left alone to do its thing. If you want to manual trade this robot, do not complain about its performance. I can see why Mr. Price is getting short with some of those on the thread, if your not following the configuration guidelines or running it properly, you should keep your comment to yourselves.... IMO
In lite of doing on 1:50 fxcm, "STUNNING!" And last week was a highly volatile one too, like WO!
don't believe 99.9% of the EA e-ads out there my friends!
Medlem sedan Feb 09, 2010
224 inlägg
Jan 17, 2015 at 21:10
supernova01 posted:
well, i will purchase it, but if i'll see notprofitable trading in 2011-2013 u will give me 10k$, ok?
You sound like a real doughball with absolutely no sense whatsoever. Do yourself a favour and don't spend your lifetime savings on this EA. We really don't want another idiot messaging because he lost 1 trade which because you are greedy you will take excessive risks and blow your account up and then blame the EA and come back here to criticise it.
