To use chat, please login.
Back to contacts

Forex Growth Bot

Gain : +2644.71%
Drawdown 94.46%
Pips: 8075.5
Trades 2881
Won:
Lost:
Type: Real
Leverage: 1:200
Trading: Automated

Forex Growth Bot Discussion

bch159
May 12 2011 at 15:58
32 posts
Mine closed (paper trading) on collective fx in profit - I never intercede with the ea's trading.

airalex
May 12 2011 at 16:10
22 posts
someone has the same results as on monitoring?

expat1967
May 12 2011 at 16:43
11 posts
The stealth feature makes this Bot so stealth that even traders dont know whats happening... Thats a serious laps...

The developer can pull TP/SL easily out which is essential for traders to determine the trade status. It can be stealthed on chart/server accordingly upon Broker concerns.

Cheers

cunod
May 12 2011 at 16:43
97 posts

tola posted:
    

I'm using the same broker as FGB and the trades are opened similar to the records here. The last period I have had differences in closing, and certainly the last three which is still open and I intend to leave them for the bot to close even tho they're closed by FGB.
I have been very happy with the Growthbot so far, but if the FGB team keeps closing trades manually and the records doesn't reflect the bot's behaviour, I'm inclined to not trust it so much anymore. I really don't want to handle trades manually and be forced to be watching the bot - that's not why I bought it.


//Mr T


Ok, I am going to give FGB the benifit of the doubt on this comment. Mind you I have no proof to back this up and it is just speculation. Can anyone confirm if this issue has occurred before the implementation of v1.4 (which I think was about a week or 2 ago). They updated it due to some verification issue when you attached it to the chart. I am aware of this because I experienced it. As a speculation could they have screwed something up in the closing procedure due to this fix.

cunod
May 12 2011 at 16:50
97 posts

expat1967 posted:
    The stealth feature makes this Bot so stealth that even traders dont know whats happening... Thats a serious laps...

The developer can pull TP/SL easily out which is essential for traders to determine the trade status. It can be stealthed on chart/server accordingly upon Broker concerns.

Cheers


My opinion on the stealth features are they should post a TP/SL that is so out of bounds its not going to matter to the broker in the event of a win lose scenario.

For example if it buys the EURUSD set the stop loss at 1.00000 and the take profit at 2.00000

Unless there is more to a EA stealth feature, I'm not to familiar with EA scripts.

Or did you mean something else by this comment?

forextraveler (memforex)
May 12 2011 at 17:10
119 posts
I have the proof that it's not a broker issue. Look tghe screenshot, come from 1 minut chart of my platform. at 05.12.2011 10:45 they close the position at 1.41320, at the same time my broker was exactly at the same price, there's no difference. Look at the attached file.

Attachments:


airalex
May 12 2011 at 17:22
22 posts
They are not honest to us.

cunod
May 12 2011 at 17:25
97 posts

prototipo posted:
    I have the proof that it's not a broker issue. Look tghe screenshot, come from 1 minut chart of my platform. at 05.12.2011 10:45 they close the position at 1.41320, at the same time my broker was exactly at the same price, there's no difference. Look at the attached file.



FGB do you wish to comment on this?

forextraveler (memforex)
May 12 2011 at 17:27
119 posts

expat1967 posted:
    The stealth feature makes this Bot so stealth that even traders dont know whats happening... Thats a serious laps...

The developer can pull TP/SL easily out which is essential for traders to determine the trade status. It can be stealthed on chart/server accordingly upon Broker concerns.

Cheers


yeah I think the same, now I configured ASSIGN TP AND SL to True, so I can check it.
But I have a doubt, does it works with ECN broker that not accept SL and TP when opening order but only in later when the order is already open? does it work? I would please an answer from FGB staff.

Oliver (Kollinger)
May 12 2011 at 17:47
30 posts
I am sorry that I have to say that, but at the moment I am really pissed of!!! I came at home from work a few minutes ago, switch on my PC and what I have to see?! FGB made 195.8 Pips profit in the last 3 trades and at the same three trades I have lost around 180 pips! Do you guys from FGB want to cheat me?! I had the same trades, with the same opening time, I use as well the SAME BROKER (ThinkForex) - How can this be? I am only a moment away to request refund!!! I am so angry at the moment! And you guys are not able at least to post any comment here!

Please login to comment .