FOREX SCALPINO ROBOT (LIVE 1) (FXScalpinoRobot) Diskusia

FXScalpinoRobot

Členom od May 03, 2013 49 príspevkov

Jul 14, 2013 at 06:22

Členom od May 03, 2013 49 príspevkov

Dear FxMasterGuru,
we recommend to use Variable spread. That is logic for scalping EA.
Our EA don't have any issue. We think that you need to learn more about spreads and closing of trades. How can trade to be closed whit 4 pips TP if broker increase spread?

As we said about 10/July, then happen 3 news whit highest impact on market whit only 1 hour deference between news.
So, here no discuss anymore.

Kind regards.

deysmacro

Členom od Jul 17, 2012 274 príspevkov

Jul 14, 2013 at 06:38

Členom od Jul 17, 2012 274 príspevkov

@FxMasterGuru

I pity you. The vendor really don't understand what you are trying to say. 😲

Past experience usually helps present self

FxMasterGuru

Členom od May 04, 2012 1534 príspevkov

Jul 14, 2013 at 17:44

Členom od May 04, 2012 1534 príspevkov

deysmacro posted:
@FxMasterGuru

I pity you. The vendor really don't understand what you are trying to say. 😲

Thanks for the sympathy! I guess at least you understand my concerns. I assume that the vendor does not WANT to understand my concerns and arrogantly makes me look like a noob...

Anyway, for the 3rd and the last time: When the spread becomes larger (> set spread limit) the EA stops working. Completely. It does not do anything from that point: it does not open trades (which is good), but it does not do anything else either which can be a problem.

Example: On many occasions the EA's marketable(!) profit was at +7 pips, but with a hidden +4 pips TP it has not closed the trade at +4 pips because the spread was >limit. So I closed it manually at marketable +7 pips. So the larger spread should not prohibit taking profits. But it does because the EA stops working.

With the same logic: If a trade is opened (while the spread was < limit) and in the NEXT SECOND the spread become larger, the EA stops working completely and "FORGETS" placing a stop loss. That is what happened on my account letting a trade run into -250 pips loss.

It is very sad that the EA vendor ignores my constructive criticism about a bug which should be fixed ASAP, so others can avoid having a trade running "naked" without stop loss. It may happen only once in 100,000 trades (i.e. with a chance of 0.001%), but in this case mine was that 100,000th... So it was a 100% event for me.

Please click "Vouch" if you liked my post. If not, just put me on your Blocked list. :o)

johnnycash

Členom od Feb 23, 2013 28 príspevkov

Jul 14, 2013 at 17:47

Členom od Feb 23, 2013 28 príspevkov

he prolly understand it very well, but is afraid that when he admits "yes, that's a glitch that no SL is set when spread widens suddenly", that people claim compensation for the damage the bot made.

really bad programming has been taking place when the bot isnt able to react to such market conditions cause they happen all the time.

and really really bad customer service he is showing here... that is disgusting, claiming the customer is too stupid ... beyond words.

deysmacro

Členom od Jul 17, 2012 274 príspevkov

Jul 15, 2013 at 02:31 (upravené Jul 15, 2013 at 02:32)

Členom od Jul 17, 2012 274 príspevkov

@FxMasterGuru & @johnnycash

Well, I did explain how to circumvent the bot bug (weakness) in the previous post. In fact, I can do it pretty easily since I did have such problem in the past.

If the vendor still can't figure it out how to do the proper spread logic coding, I think I can safely say that the EA is not really his/her creation. 😀

Past experience usually helps present self

FXScalpinoRobot

Členom od May 03, 2013 49 príspevkov

Jul 15, 2013 at 06:06

Členom od May 03, 2013 49 príspevkov

Dear FxMasterGuru , you can cry every day here, but our EA don't have any issue.
If you had any problem, you need to reinstal EA, just go in member area of our website and download.

-250 not possible every trade have SL: -31 pips, everyone can see here on Myfxbook on 3 accounts.

Kind Regards.

deysmacro

Členom od Jul 17, 2012 274 príspevkov

Jul 15, 2013 at 06:12 (upravené Jul 15, 2013 at 06:16)

Členom od Jul 17, 2012 274 príspevkov

@FxMasterGuru

I am speechless. Can't believe this is happening right before my eyes and witnessing this turn of the events. 😲

Past experience usually helps present self

FxMasterGuru

Členom od May 04, 2012 1534 príspevkov

Jul 15, 2013 at 06:19

Členom od May 04, 2012 1534 príspevkov

johnnycash posted:
he prolly understand it very well, but is afraid that when he admits "yes, that's a glitch that no SL is set when spread widens suddenly", that people claim compensation for the damage the bot made.

really bad programming has been taking place when the bot isnt able to react to such market conditions cause they happen all the time.

and really really bad customer service he is showing here... that is disgusting, claiming the customer is too stupid ... beyond words.

Thanks, Johnny! I guess, Forex is in the "twilight zone" in regard to taking responsibility for paid goods if damages happen due to the product's malfunction. In a "perfect world" and especially in the USA that would be the norm and the expected action from any vendor.

Please click "Vouch" if you liked my post. If not, just put me on your Blocked list. :o)

FXScalpinoRobot

Členom od May 03, 2013 49 príspevkov

Jul 15, 2013 at 06:22

Členom od May 03, 2013 49 príspevkov

deysmacro's, who are you? Are you our client? What is your e-mail?
Why you talking about our EA, if you don't use him???

Kind Regards.

deysmacro

Členom od Jul 17, 2012 274 príspevkov

Jul 15, 2013 at 06:30 (upravené Jul 15, 2013 at 06:46)

Členom od Jul 17, 2012 274 príspevkov

@FXScalpinoRobot

Just a passing by EA vendor 😎

Past experience usually helps present self

FXScalpinoRobot

Členom od May 03, 2013 49 príspevkov

Jul 17, 2013 at 05:49

Členom od May 03, 2013 49 príspevkov

NEWS: as we promised, we added one more LIVE (Real) account, but this time on EXNESS broker.

https://www.myfxbook.com/members/FXScalpinoRobot/forex-scalpino-robot-live-3/640429

Regards.

FXScalpinoRobot

Členom od May 03, 2013 49 príspevkov

Jul 21, 2013 at 06:21

Členom od May 03, 2013 49 príspevkov

Hi Everyone,

NewsFilter has been added to ForexScalpinoRobot. You can now run it 100% automatic.

deysmacro

Členom od Jul 17, 2012 274 príspevkov

Jul 21, 2013 at 06:55 (upravené Jul 21, 2013 at 06:57)

Členom od Jul 17, 2012 274 príspevkov

I bet the question below would be asked soon enough by FxMasterGuru 😎

@FXScalpinoRobot

How was the spread logic control system? Would the ea stop managing floating trades if the current broker spread is more than the allowable range?

It is to my believe the ea would stop managing floating trades when the current broker spread is more than the allowable range.

Past experience usually helps present self

profix

Členom od Jul 15, 2011 126 príspevkov

Jul 22, 2013 at 04:34

Členom od Jul 15, 2011 126 príspevkov

FXScalpinoRobot posted:
Hi Everyone,

NewsFilter has been added to ForexScalpinoRobot. You can now run it 100% automatic.

Hi vendor,
got this losing control on floating trade bug, caused by bad coding, fixed yet?

quote
The spread logic have been put at the upper part of the whole coding process, so, when the spread logic hits, it will set its logic top priority and then stop the rest of the whole EA logics.

To circumvent this weakness, the spread logic only needs to be placed inline with the trade opening logic. A simple TRUE or FALSE is all it takes. When the spread logic hits, it will stop opening trade but still controls any floating trade. Its that simple.

Most probably the EA author don't realize how simple it is to code the EA in such way.
quote

aeronthomas

Členom od Dec 04, 2010 1447 príspevkov

Jul 22, 2013 at 08:14

Členom od Dec 04, 2010 1447 príspevkov

I was considering buying this EA, and have been monitoring it's performance for some time, due to the issues of widening spreads and the EA stops when this happens and doesn't manage open trades i.e. put in the hard stop loss, I won't purchase until word is received that this issue is fixed, I can't afford -250 pip losses. Good to see a news filter has been added.

deysmacro

Členom od Jul 17, 2012 274 príspevkov

Jul 22, 2013 at 08:24

Členom od Jul 17, 2012 274 príspevkov

Well, the vendor seems don't understand of what I have said in the previous post bout the spread thingy. 😇

Past experience usually helps present self

FxMasterGuru

Členom od May 04, 2012 1534 príspevkov

Jul 22, 2013 at 10:19

Členom od May 04, 2012 1534 príspevkov

deysmacro posted:
Well, the vendor seems don't understand of what I have said in the previous post bout the spread thingy. 😇

Yes, it is very unfortunate. Especially that my account was the suffering "guinea pig" of this bug costing me a LOT.

I will not use this EA until this bug is fixed. It was enough to face an open trade in -300 pips and without SL...

Please click "Vouch" if you liked my post. If not, just put me on your Blocked list. :o)

ForexPro

Členom od May 10, 2010 360 príspevkov

Jul 22, 2013 at 19:38

Členom od May 10, 2010 360 príspevkov

On donna forum a guy named John popped up to take over the support for the EA, but still no info there from him about the bug...
http://www.donnaforex.com/forum/index.php?topic=10522.15

FXScalpinoRobot

Členom od May 03, 2013 49 príspevkov

Jul 28, 2013 at 18:35

Členom od May 03, 2013 49 príspevkov

ATTENTION!
at Wednesday, 31/July at 18:00 (GMT) > FOMC Statement

WE RECOMMEND TO ALL OUR CLIENTS TO STOP EA THAT DAY! REASON: EA IS SENSITIVE ON FOMC NEWS.

........................................................................................
current date and time: Sunday (28/Jluy), 18:34 (GMT)

EURUSD	1.13248	GBPUSD	1.3323	AUDUSD	0.64069
USDJPY	143.013	USDCAD	1.37922	USDCHF	0.82629

Advertisement

FOREX SCALPINO ROBOT (LIVE 1) Diskusia