เพื่อใช้การแชท โปรดเข้าสู่ระบบ
กลับไปที่รายชื่อ

DEMO ACCOUNT vs LIVE ACCOUNT

damienp (damienp)
May 04 2017 at 14:27
23 โพสต์
5 months with demo, for over a year only real account😝

kieran (snapdragon1970)
May 05 2017 at 12:16
1945 โพสต์
Lex Van Dam has a free month for anyone interested in market view, well worth a look , some of the data might surprise you.

vontogr (togr)
May 05 2017 at 12:29
4862 โพสต์
snapdragon1970 posted:
Lex Van Dam has a free month for anyone interested in market view, well worth a look , some of the data might surprise you.


Does he have a verified account here on mFB?

kieran (snapdragon1970)
May 05 2017 at 12:39
1945 โพสต์
togr posted:
snapdragon1970 posted:
Lex Van Dam has a free month for anyone interested in market view, well worth a look , some of the data might surprise you.


Does he have a verified account here on mFB?


Who knows maybe he does ,what would you like to see in his stats?

vontogr (togr)
May 05 2017 at 13:17
4862 โพสต์
snapdragon1970 posted:
togr posted:
snapdragon1970 posted:
Lex Van Dam has a free month for anyone interested in market view, well worth a look , some of the data might surprise you.


Does he have a verified account here on mFB?


Who knows maybe he does ,what would you like to see in his stats?


as otherwise you just advertise some service completely unrelated to this forum

xgavinc
May 05 2017 at 14:07
235 โพสต์
togr posted:
snapdragon1970 posted:
Lex Van Dam has a free month for anyone interested in market view, well worth a look , some of the data might surprise you.


Does he have a verified account here on mFB?


You don't know who Lex van Dam is!!!? 😲

I doubt he has an account here (in fact I'm pretty sure he doesn't), he is a hedge fund manager... a very successful one with high end clientele. He only recently started courses on forex, his training focus has primarily been about shares and related 'company' type instruments (etf, cfd, etc.).

But yes, doesn't relate to the forum topic at all.

For every loss there should be at least an equal and opposite profit.
vontogr (togr)
May 05 2017 at 14:33
4862 โพสต์
xgavinc posted:
togr posted:
snapdragon1970 posted:
Lex Van Dam has a free month for anyone interested in market view, well worth a look , some of the data might surprise you.


Does he have a verified account here on mFB?


You don't know who Lex van Dam is!!!? 😲

I doubt he has an account here (in fact I'm pretty sure he doesn't), he is a hedge fund manager... a very successful one with high end clientele. He only recently started courses on forex, his training focus has primarily been about shares and related 'company' type instruments (etf, cfd, etc.).

But yes, doesn't relate to the forum topic at all.


I dont care
this topic is about demo trading vs real.
If you need to promote someone pay the ad

vontogr (togr)
May 05 2017 at 14:34
4862 โพสต์
BTW successful trader trades for living
and does NOT need to sell any courses

kieran (snapdragon1970)
May 05 2017 at 16:29
1945 โพสต์
Seems like your against people getting free information that is actually useful and it does cover forex, I had to laugh when you asked if he had a myfxbook account, why not sell courses if your a successful hedge fund manager its another income stream plus he enjoys what he does.

vontogr (togr)
May 06 2017 at 07:42
4862 โพสต์
snapdragon1970 posted:
Seems like your against people getting free information that is actually useful and it does cover forex, I had to laugh when you asked if he had a myfxbook account, why not sell courses if your a successful hedge fund manager its another income stream plus he enjoys what he does.


The point is
Successful hedge manager has no need to sell courses.
The point is
how can he prove his success
The point is the website is not much convincing
The point is that this advertisement clearly does not belong to forum about demo vs real trading.
etc..
I am done with that matter and you should better stick to forum topics dear.

Private Trader (privtrader)
May 07 2017 at 06:38
27 โพสต์
always live account😀

hjacob
May 08 2017 at 07:35
30 โพสต์
PanMajk posted:
hjacob posted:
Yes absolutely, demo and live accounts are more or less same. The difference is psychological as while trading in live account our real money is at stake which make one feel more concerned. However, yes having well developed strategy can make you succeed and overcome this psychological barrier. Demo accounts can also be used for testing strategies before going live.


I cannot disagree, however I feel like when I start live trading, my strategy is going to fail.. with numerous positions in a row so that my start is going to be super hard. I guess there is no other way than trying. The Fear is strong in me. Perhaps I need a few more months of practice. Does it lead to conclusion 'demo trade for as long as you need to gain full confidence with your skills'? Anyone had similar feelings?


Yes it’s true that one must demo trade for as long till he gains enough confidence. However, even starting with the small real account should be taken time. If a trader is not confident then he must not get indulge in live trading so early.

MrMajk (PanMajk)
May 21 2017 at 07:49
10 โพสต์
Rihann posted:


Hi! I had not read this thread, but you're totally wrong if you think a demo account works like a real one. Since then there is nothing similar in the absolute, the demo account proves the broker in the market, there is no guarantee that good trades and winnings in the demo account will occur the same in the real account. That is not how it works.


So you mean demo account is not on forex at all and has different laws? Or you simply mean that price movements are never 100% sure and holy grails dont exist? - which is not solid enough imo to prove that demo is totally different. If I develop my own personal working strategy on demo account I am 100% sure that it is going to fail on live account because demo is totally different? Is there any guarantee in forex at all, at any time?

Professional4X
May 22 2017 at 06:32
1189 โพสต์

So you mean demo account is not on forex at all and has different laws? Or you simply mean that price movements are never 100% sure and holy grails dont exist?


You will not find a system that has a 100% perfect always win history.

Holy grails do not exist.

I suppose that in theory they 'could' exist, but the likely hood of it being ever made available to the general public would be infinitesimally small. Why would anyone release it and make it available? They'd basically have infinite wealth at their disposal.

which is not solid enough imo to prove that demo is totally different.

Demo account price feeds are often different from Live account price feeds.
Different spreads, different response times, etc etc etc.


If I develop my own personal working strategy on demo account I am 100% sure that it is going to fail on live account because demo is totally different? Is there any guarantee in forex at all, at any time?


If you feel 100% that you're going to fail on a live account, then you should absolutely NOT put money in your live account.

You asked if there is any guarantee at all? NONE. There is no guarantee of making money with forex.

If you think you are going to fail, then you've already failed, and should probably keep learning and practicing your strategy, or not trade at all.



If it looks too good to be true, it's probably a scam! Let the buyer beware.
MrMajk (PanMajk)
May 24 2017 at 06:30
10 โพสต์
In fact all my questions above were rhetorical. I used such measures to prove that I disagree with a tesis like: 'demo is totally different just because'. But anyway thank you for your comprehensive and serious answer.

The only noticeable difference to trader-wannabe like me is that with real account, real emotions start to interfere.
 

vontogr (togr)
May 24 2017 at 07:08
4862 โพสต์
It depends on broker.
On good broker you wont see much difference demo vs. real.
Moreover if your strategy has lets say 10% a month profit on demo it should have at least 9% a month on real.
P.S. did you ever try to copy trades from demo to real to compare execution?

Professional4X
May 24 2017 at 07:23
1189 โพสต์
biagio posted:
@Professional4X Wow ... very good participation.


Thank you. :)

biagio posted:
I do not understand why people believe that in forex trading they should have a guarantee of profit. Simply if you are good at trading you will make money, if not, you lose money, it is realistic.


New investors fund a small account with a few hundred dollars and then expect to become billionaires over night. :)

I agree with you. If a person develops good skills, controlled emotional discipline, and a solid understanding of what really moves the markets, you can make a very good income from trading. But it takes a lot of work and education in order to make a good income from it.












If it looks too good to be true, it's probably a scam! Let the buyer beware.
mlawson71
May 24 2017 at 11:42
1487 โพสต์
Do any traders actually believe that they will have any guarantees for profit? Usually even when you learn the basics you're told that Forex trading carries quite a bit of inherent risk.

vontogr (togr)
May 24 2017 at 13:47
4862 โพสต์
Professional4X posted:
biagio posted:
@Professional4X Wow ... very good participation.


Thank you. :)

biagio posted:
I do not understand why people believe that in forex trading they should have a guarantee of profit. Simply if you are good at trading you will make money, if not, you lose money, it is realistic.


New investors fund a small account with a few hundred dollars and then expect to become billionaires over night. :)

I agree with you. If a person develops good skills, controlled emotional discipline, and a solid understanding of what really moves the markets, you can make a very good income from trading. But it takes a lot of work and education in order to make a good income from it.


Well there is a huge problem of under capitalization leading to over trading.
User with like 1000 deposit would like to see $200 each month. This is not realistic for long term and at the end he will end up with zeroed account.

Karel (Bohdan73)
May 26 2017 at 06:14
51 โพสต์
Professional4X posted:
I agree with you. If a person develops good skills, controlled emotional discipline, and a solid understanding of what really moves the markets, you can make a very good income from trading. But it takes a lot of work and education in order to make a good income from it.


This is the holy grail of trading what you explain. Everyone should strive for it 😄 I agree that it takes lot of work!

โปรดเข้าสู่ระบบเพื่อแสดงความคิดเห็น