กำลังโหลด...
Continue to Myfxbook.com
Continue to Myfxbook.com
Čeština
Deutsch
English
Español
Français
Indonesia
Latviešu
Melayu
Polski
Português(Brasil)
Português(Portugal)
Slovenčina
Svenska
Türkçe
Vietnamese
Русский
हिंदी
ไทย
日本語
简体字
繁體中文
한국어
ลงชื่อเข้าใช้
ลงทะเบียน
Open an account with FOREX.com
FX Tools:
ปฏิทินเศรษฐกิจ
Interest Rates
FX Calculators
ข่าว
สเปรด
ความเชื่อมั่น
แผนที่ฟอเร็กซ์มาแรง
ความสัมพันธ์
Market Hours
หน้าหลัก
gmfx
โพสต์
แชร์
แชร์หน้านี้!
Advertisement
โพสต์โดย
gmfx
growth graph equity line
ใน
ทั่วไป
Jun 01, 2011 at 00:17
Hey speki,A day away brought some advice.Indeed, I must say I have neglected some important details when I wrote down the math.And recognising that means I now understand why the MyFxBook team has designed the Growth chart this way.On the other hand, I must say I still regard it as potentially misleading.So what have I realised that wasn't right in the math?Well let's have a little repeat for sake of clarity:Now, what the Growth chart plots, is not b'/b but the cumulative amount of b'/b since t0 (start) up to a given day t: sum(b'/b).So this was my mistake.Let's add thi...
growth graph equity line
ใน
ทั่วไป
May 30, 2011 at 20:41
Hey speki,I'm only a newbie trader trying to understand the use of these tools and I give my feedback hoping that can help improve things.I think myfxbook offers a fantastic platform and we can only be grateful they made it freely available.Surely they make it for money and I hope they can keep making more by offering even better tools.So, obviously I understand thousands have been and are using the charts as they are and making the most of them.In my small experience I found that the growth chart in particular offers some reasons to doubt the way it's designed.Lately, I've found m...
growth graph equity line
ใน
ทั่วไป
May 30, 2011 at 16:32
Speki,I'm not so sure about your sense of humour.I'm simply pointing out how in the growth chart my equity appears to perform way better than it actually does if the equity line is accepted as equity growth, as the title of the chart suggests.I have a system giving an equity increasing by 20% and a chart plotting it at 60%.Worse, when equity goes into a loss of 30% this chart still shows it in the positive by 10%.I do find this misleading, if you don't good on you, but please respect my voicing my doubts.
growth graph equity line
ใน
ทั่วไป
May 30, 2011 at 16:22
It remains that the current growth chart instead of comparing balance growth with equity growth, compares balance growth with the total value of equity proportion of balance scaled down by the balance growth ... meaningful?I'm really not sure of the use of this, of one thing I'm sure: it's misleading to plot these two lines together in what's called a growth chart.From a growth chart I expect to see how a trading system has performed on a given account in terms of (relative) balance growth and (relative) equity growth, if either goes in the negative it must show so.With a bit o...
growth graph equity line
ใน
ทั่วไป
May 30, 2011 at 14:41
Ok, thanks for making this clear, Ethan, but still how meaningful is it?It leads us to compare an increment (that of the account balance) not with the increment in equity for that account, but with the portion of equity held for that account scaled down by the increment of the account!! (perverse!)What information do we gather from such comparison?It's not just useless, it's misleading ... think about it ... (ultimately it's dimensionally wrong: we must compare increments with increments) If you want to check the growth of a system as an indication of its performance you want to lo...
growth graph equity line
ใน
ทั่วไป
May 30, 2011 at 12:03
Hi Ethan,Thanks a lot for answering this.However, I have to say this doesn't make a lot of sense to me: if this was right the equity line should start at 100%, right?Why does it start at 0%, then?I would expect any growth chart to start at 0%.But what's the purpose if it plots a figure of ~60% when the actual increase is only ~20%?That's a very large difference and the value that would be most informative about the system is the ~20% growth in equity, rather than the fact that equity is at ~60% of account balance in that moment (while it's still unclear why it starts at 0% inst...
growth graph equity line
ใน
ทั่วไป
May 29, 2011 at 12:57
Thanks for your reply, speki.The concept of equity is very clear.But that's not my problem.My problem is with the growth chart.It shows the line of growth of the account (in red) and the line of growth of the equity held for that account (in yellow).The problem is that the equity growth is definitely very different from what this graph seems to indicate.For instance, my account shows a growth of about 110% (which makes perfect sense, since the account started at $50k and has now reached about $105k so +$55k), however it also shows a growth of equity of about 60% when my equity is next to $...
growth graph equity line
ใน
ทั่วไป
May 25, 2011 at 22:58
I don't understand how the equity line is supposed to be calculated in the growth graph.Can anyone help?Thanks
You have an Ad Blocker!
Myfxbook is a site supported by advertisements. Here are two ways for you to continue browsing:
Ad Free Subscription
หรือ
Disable your Ad Blocker
Already subscribed?
ลงชื่อเข้าใช้
คุณไม่ได้เข้าสู่ระบบ
คุณสมบัตินี้มีให้สำหรับสมาชิกที่ลงทะเบียนเท่านั้น
การลงทะเบียนนั้นฟรีและใช้เวลาน้อยกว่าหนึ่งนาที
คลิกปุ่มลงทะเบียนเพื่อดำเนินการต่อ
เว้นแต่คุณจะเป็นสมาชิกและเพลิดเพลินกับบริการของเราอยู่แล้ว ให้เข้าสู่ระบบ
Keep up to date with the markets
Enable notifications to receive real-time important market updates:
ปฏิทินเศรษฐกิจ
ข่าวฟอเร็กซ์
You can disable notifications at any time from your browser.
Unblock Notifications
You've blocked browser notifications for Myfxbook.com. Please enable it:
You can disable notifications at any time from your browser.
ก่อนหน้า
การสำรวจความเห็น
จริง
