เพื่อใช้การแชท โปรดเข้าสู่ระบบ
กลับไปที่รายชื่อ

Tickmill คะแนนรีวิว


คะแนนรวม: 3.7 / 5

คะแนนโหวตทั้งหมด: 257
แพลตฟอร์ม
1
ราคา
1
บริการลูกค้า
1
คุณสมบัติ
1
1 - แย่ที่สุด 5 - ดีที่สุด

Tickmill การสนทนา

14 โพสต์
Tickmill is again in iFX Expo in Hong Kong along with 2 other brokers that I am using. I thought it might be useful to share with the MYfxbook community.
https://tickmill.com/news/tickmill-sponsors-the-ifx-expo-asia-in-hong-kong/
1 โพสต์
I have been working with them for like 6 months. During the trades I have not come across any problem. Fills, take profits, stop losses are quite good. Spreads are favorable.

But when it comes to withdrawing money I want to share my bad experience with them. I never withdrawed any money quite a while. When I first requested withdraw all went nice. They paid back to my card that I deposited money with. But after 15 days I could not see money on my account. They said withdraw processed succesfuly on our side and gave me ARN code. But my bank could not see the money. Also they can not verify ARN code in here Turkey. No bank use this code in Turkey. I asked my bank a lot and they could not give me any positive answer. I went back again Tickmill and they did not give me any solution as well. They ask an official letter from my bank that states they can not track the money via ARN code but they said that we can not prepare that document. My bank said that in order to investigate this process we need a receipt. Tickmill refuse giving receipt and giving answer about which way use while they sending the money.

So at the and it looks like my money went to trash. The amount was not that big. I expected maybe Tickmill can handle this process for once in my favour for further cooperations. I am thinking working with another company now. Its just disappointment for a company I thought they were nice but can not give me solution.
2 โพสต์
... often I have better results then signal provider :)

LOL😀
14 โพสต์
Tickmill is the finalist together with Saxo and CMC in the Best Forex Broker award category of LondonSummit which will take place next week.

ไฟล์แนบ :

1 โพสต์
I have traded with Tickmill for 2 years.
They always give me a sense of trust, occasionally slippage, but compared to other brokers, the trading experience is still very good. They are honest.
1 โพสต์
I have a pro account with Tickmill and I do scalping on eurusd using tf on 1 min and 5 min. Until now I never had any issue. The server is stable and the execution is super fast, reliable with low latency. By doing scalping my requirements are to have a platform that never freezes closing my positions without too much slippage and in a few seconds. With Tickmill all of this is possible and thanks to low spreads and commissions I can work with a good edge by using trading strategies with low expectancy as well. Btw I saw on their site they won a prize as best trading forex conditions: https://tickmill.com/news/best-forex-trading-conditions/
I recommend it definitely
1 โพสต์
I tried them for a few months. I opened demo account first and used 3 different EA to test strategies. 2 EA traded very good, 1 account was killed....hahaha. Too much risk in 1 trade on news breakout. After I installed my EA and traded with welcome account. Little profit, but no loss. Now I am ready to start small account with my EA with real server.
I tried other 2 brokers with same EA before. But Tickmill give low spread. And I found commision very low, my another brokers take more commision 2 times!!!
So time to try another broker with real account!
I also asked for bonus my account manager, but they say they are not bonus broker but they cover my deposit and withdrawal fees. Also not bad. Also they do not change leverage in news period like my other 1 broker changes.
1 โพสต์
I use Tickmill UK for almost a year now and I am extremely pleased with their services. Spreads are good, can't complain about execution, client support and withdrawals are always very quick. I use them for trading mql signals and often I have better results then signal provider :)
3 โพสต์
I still have an small account with them, i can tell that the execution is pretty bad. Some weeks they have been very good, then suddenly the spreads increased and execution was a pain... not just for me, was just bad in general from june-august this year (EURUSD) now they are a bit better again. I would never trade with them with big money, my mate had 1$ slippage with a bigegr XAUUSD trade once.... 1$!! For scalping and spread sesitive strategies... be careful. Long term they are better, with small lot you get better prices and swaps are pretty good. It's not that they are the worst, with cashback they are pretty cheap. Some may be happy with them.

Note that i always compare at least 3 brokers with same EA, so most of the time they trade alle the same 1:1, without this kind of testing you may dont notice execution problems at all.

14 โพสต์
Tickmill recently acquired Vipro Markets and now has 3 licenced companies in the group. Is the service quality of Vipro the same as Tickmill?
https://tickmill.com/news/tickmill-group-grows-stronger-with-the-acquisition-of-vipro-markets/
5 โพสต์
Highly recommending you, stay away from them. Have been trading with lot of brokers, haven't seen such execution nowhere of any order. Every one who is happy, don't count anything. With small spread, you actually trade with high spread forexample eurusd at least 1-1,5p + commission.

If you ar swing trader, then i cant tell you much, as those small 1-1,5 difference is not big deal. But scalping and day traders, no way.
89 โพสต์
Looking for my new broker and I found lot of this about tickmill:

(more: https://www.forexpeacearmy.com/forex-reviews/8718/www.tickmill.com)

ไฟล์แนบ :

Im writing about my experiences, so yours can be different ;)
5 โพสต์
I'm running my EA on 3 broker to compare the differencies; I've noticed that at breakout levels, Tickmill is increasing their spread with more than 20 points and the price was jumping up and down; at the same time the spread with IC-Markets and Darwinex were normal and stable resulting a loss on Tickmill, while the others resulted in profit.
13 โพสต์
my only complaint about tickmill is I dont get 0 spread as their mention in the opening account form. I can easily see raw core spread with 0 for main pair like eurusd jpyusd gbpusd with other ecn broker. I consider their spread is high on average and this is not good for prime broker like tickmill. I can mention few broker here that I can trade easily with 0 spread, but just leave it to tickmill to rectify this issue. after month of trading with them I never never see 0 spread on eurusd. prime broker should have better quote.
13 โพสต์
mka78 posted:
eds_ posted:
It is very interesting, every one have so positive reviews of them. Looks like I only one who have problems.

Can some one check and confirm that they don't have such problems as I have, before I contacting them.

All, I mean all my orders getting filed with worth price as they are requested. If I set order to enter market for buy at price 0,0020 order fills with 0,0025 and if my SL is set at 0,0015 it will end up with 0,0010 and opposite if I set my order to sell at price 0,003 it will open at price 0,0025 and SL will be fill from 0,004 to 0,0045.

Price is correct only if I do trading manually, then I cant see any slipping of price. But orders 100% are worse for me.

I just made statistic, and find out that in average on this way my commission to them is no 4$ per lot but more then 10$. And that's a lot.

Even on statements, clearly seen that order is set at that price, but close is different.
Hope to hear from your experience.

I have the same issue here and i can confirm what you wrote and that's the reason I am withdrawing all my funds and profits and switching to another broker. I prefer a transparent Market Maker broker over a broker who is claiming himself ECN NDD DMA STP.

are you new to trading forex. You will not get the same price for your stop, this is normal. understand how the bid and offer work first before complaint :)
Pip Vision
10 โพสต์
Fakeera posted:
Tickmill is not real ECN broker.
I asked them proof it they are real ECN broker and in return thy closed all my accounts without any notice.
More over I requested the same thing to Vipro Markets. They did the same.
Note that Tickmill is white label solution provider to Vipro Markets

Bro that's the BS, its not a valid reason to close your accounts. As a proof they are ECN you can check their institutional branch https://www.tickmillprime.com, they offer liquidity for other brokers.
And here is my account with them https://www.myfxbook.com/members/woodcutter/pulse-tickmill-real/1757067, been there from August 2016, although doing manual trading I don't care about spreads much, I still had some cases during news trading where they reimbursed some of my loss due to off market fill. They are 100% honest as they care about clients and do entertain our requests.
2 โพสต์
Tickmill is not real ECN broker.
I asked them proof it they are real ECN broker and in return thy closed all my accounts without any notice.
More over I requested the same thing to Vipro Markets. They did the same.
Note that Tickmill is white label solution provider to Vipro Markets
3 โพสต์
eds_ posted:
It is very interesting, every one have so positive reviews of them. Looks like I only one who have problems.

Can some one check and confirm that they don't have such problems as I have, before I contacting them.

All, I mean all my orders getting filed with worth price as they are requested. If I set order to enter market for buy at price 0,0020 order fills with 0,0025 and if my SL is set at 0,0015 it will end up with 0,0010 and opposite if I set my order to sell at price 0,003 it will open at price 0,0025 and SL will be fill from 0,004 to 0,0045.

Price is correct only if I do trading manually, then I cant see any slipping of price. But orders 100% are worse for me.

I just made statistic, and find out that in average on this way my commission to them is no 4$ per lot but more then 10$. And that's a lot.

Even on statements, clearly seen that order is set at that price, but close is different.
Hope to hear from your experience.

I have the same issue here and i can confirm what you wrote and that's the reason I am withdrawing all my funds and profits and switching to another broker. I prefer a transparent Market Maker broker over a broker who is claiming himself ECN NDD DMA STP.
2 โพสต์
Im using tickmill offshore to split test many of my algos, and they have been well performing thus far. Their back office is really nice and intuitive. Im using them and Mt.Cook exclusively now. Very happy with both
1 โพสต์
Ottimo broker con spread e condizioni assolutamente competitive e praticamente introvabili per i traders retail. La velocità di esecuzione sia durante il fast market che durante le normali ore di contrattazioni è assolutamente degna di nota.
โปรดเข้าสู่ระบบเพื่อแสดงความคิดเห็น
Compare Forex spreads in real time สเปรดฟอเร็กซ์